Home / Blog / How Do I Screen Tenants Without Making Mistakes?
16 October 2026

How Do I Screen Tenants Without Making Mistakes?

Finding a tenant can feel like the easy part of becoming a landlord.

You advertise the property, somebody likes it, they seem perfectly pleasant at the viewing and you agree a move-in date.

Job done.

Except this is one of the stages where rushing can create problems later.

A good tenant-screening process isn’t about trying to predict somebody’s personality or finding the person who earns the most money.

It’s about establishing, fairly and consistently, whether the proposed tenancy appears affordable, whether the information you’ve been given checks out and whether the applicant meets the relevant legal requirements.

And in England, the rules landlords need to work within changed significantly during 2026.

When I speak with landlords, particularly people buying their first rental property, I think one principle is worth remembering:

Don’t choose tenants on instinct. Build a process you can explain.

That process protects both you and the applicant.

What Does Tenant Screening Actually Mean?

Tenant screening, sometimes called tenant referencing, is the process of checking a prospective tenant before agreeing to let them your property.

Depending on the circumstances, this could include checking:

  • Identity.
  • Right to Rent.
  • Income and affordability.
  • Employment.
  • Credit history.
  • Previous landlord references.
  • Previous addresses.
  • Whether a guarantor is required.

You might carry out some checks yourself or use a professional tenant-referencing company or letting agent.

But outsourcing the work doesn’t mean you can completely forget about it.

Ultimately, you still want to understand what has been checked and why somebody has either passed or failed.

Mistake Number One: Choosing the Tenant Before Doing the Checks

This is probably the easiest trap to fall into.

You meet somebody at a viewing.

They’re friendly.

They love the property.

They tell you they’ll look after it like their own.

Everything feels right.

That’s useful information, but it isn’t tenant referencing.

Equally, somebody being nervous, quiet or not particularly charismatic at a viewing tells you very little about whether they will pay the rent or look after the property.

I wouldn’t decide first and reference afterwards.

I’d have the same process for every serious applicant.

That makes your decision more objective and reduces the risk of inconsistent or discriminatory treatment.

Decide Your Criteria Before You Start

Before advertising the property, establish what you’re actually looking for.

Not:

“I want a nice tenant.”

Something measurable.

For example:

  • What is the monthly rent?
  • What affordability evidence will be required?
  • What information will applicants need to provide?
  • Will you consider a guarantor where affordability is tight?
  • Which referencing service will you use?
  • What Right to Rent checks will be required?
  • What information will you retain?

Having a process before applications arrive is much better than inventing different rules for different people.

It also gives you something you can document if your decision is ever questioned.

Don’t Assume the Highest Earner Is Automatically the Best Tenant

Income matters because the rent needs to be affordable.

But the person earning the highest salary isn’t automatically the lowest-risk tenant.

A tenant earning £60,000 could have substantial existing commitments.

Another earning £40,000 might have relatively few.

Likewise, somebody with irregular income isn’t automatically unsuitable.

They may have:

  • Savings.
  • Self-employed income.
  • Pension income.
  • Benefits.
  • Investment income.
  • A guarantor.

The purpose of affordability checking is to understand whether the rent appears sustainable.

It’s not simply a salary competition.

How Should I Check Tenant Affordability?

Referencing companies often use their own affordability calculations.

You may see requirements expressed as a multiple of the monthly rent or annual rent.

These can be useful screening tools.

But there isn’t one universal legal income multiple that every landlord must apply.

I’d want to understand the whole picture.

If the rent is £1,200 per month, ask:

What reliable income does the applicant have?

Is that income likely to continue?

Are there other sources of income?

Is a guarantor involved?

Does the referencing evidence support what the applicant has told you?

The important thing is to apply your affordability process consistently.

You Cannot Simply Say “No Benefits”

This is particularly important for landlords in England following the Renters’ Rights changes introduced in 2026.

Landlords cannot discriminate against prospective tenants because they receive benefits.

That means blanket policies such as:

“No DSS”

or

“Working professionals only because we don’t accept benefits”

can create serious problems.

You can still assess whether somebody can afford the property.

What you cannot do is disregard their benefit income purely because it is benefit income.

If Universal Credit, Child Benefit, a pension or another relevant benefit forms part of somebody’s income, it needs to be treated appropriately when carrying out the affordability assessment.

The question should be:

“Can this person afford the rent?”

not:

“Where does their income come from?”

You Cannot Reject Somebody Simply Because They Have Children

The 2026 rules in England also prohibit landlords and agents from discriminating against tenants because they have children.

Again, that doesn’t mean every property must be suitable for every household.

There may be legitimate issues involving overcrowding, licensing or the property’s physical suitability.

But a blanket:

“No children”

policy is very different.

The same principle applies more widely under equality law.

Tenant screening should not become a disguised way of selecting applicants based on protected characteristics such as race, disability, religion, sex or sexual orientation.

Use relevant financial and tenancy criteria.

Not personal assumptions.

“My Mortgage Says No Benefits” Isn’t a Safe Screening Policy

This is an important change for landlords who arranged mortgages or leases under older rules.

You may have historic documentation containing restrictions concerning tenants receiving benefits or having children.

That doesn’t mean you should automatically use those restrictions when selecting tenants today.

The law in England now prevents rental discrimination on these grounds, and certain conflicting provisions in mortgage agreements and superior leases cannot be relied upon to justify discriminatory treatment.

If you’re unsure about restrictions attached to your mortgage, lease or insurance, check the current position rather than relying on paperwork written years ago.

Right to Rent Checks Are Separate From Referencing

If your rental property is in England, you normally need to complete a Right to Rent check for every adult who will occupy the property as their only or main home.

This applies regardless of nationality.

That’s crucial.

Don’t only check somebody because you think they “look foreign” or because of their accent.

The correct process is to check all relevant adult occupiers consistently.

Depending on the applicant’s circumstances, checks can involve acceptable documents, a Home Office online service or an appropriate digital verification process.

The Home Office updated its Right to Rent guidance again in October 2026, so landlords should make sure they’re following the current procedure rather than an old checklist downloaded several years ago.

Where an occupier has a time-limited Right to Rent, follow-up checks may also be required.

Keep the necessary records securely.

Check Identity Properly

This sounds obvious, but tenant referencing is only useful if you’re checking the correct person.

Make sure the identity information provided is consistent across the application.

For example:

  • Does the name match?
  • Does the date of birth match?
  • Does the address history make sense?
  • Do the documents appear genuine?
  • Is there an unexplained discrepancy?

A discrepancy isn’t automatically evidence that somebody is being dishonest.

People change names.

Addresses can be entered incorrectly.

Documents can contain mistakes.

The sensible approach is to ask for an explanation rather than immediately assuming fraud.

Employment References Can Be Useful, But Verify Them

If somebody says they’re employed by a company, referencing may include confirming:

  • Employment status.
  • Job title.
  • Salary.
  • Length of employment.

But don’t assume that because somebody has provided an email address for “their manager”, the reference is automatically independent.

A Gmail address saying:

[email protected]

probably deserves a little more curiosity than an independently verified company contact.

Where appropriate, verify that the company exists and that the person providing the reference is genuinely connected with it.

A professional referencing company will normally have processes for doing this.

What About Self-Employed Tenants?

Being self-employed shouldn’t automatically make somebody a worse tenant.

It simply means the evidence may look different.

A self-employed applicant may be able to demonstrate income using appropriate documentation such as accounts, tax information, accountant confirmation or bank statements, depending on the referencing process.

Some people also have income that varies substantially throughout the year.

Rather than trying to squeeze everybody into the same PAYE-shaped box, the objective is to establish whether there is credible evidence that the rent is sustainable.

Should I Run a Credit Check?

Credit referencing can form a useful part of tenant screening.

Depending on the referencing service used, it may identify information such as:

  • County Court Judgments.
  • Insolvency information.
  • Credit history relevant to the assessment.
  • Address verification.

But I’d be careful about turning one credit result into an automatic judgement about somebody.

There can be context.

Perhaps an old CCJ has been satisfied.

Perhaps financial problems occurred several years ago and the applicant’s circumstances have since stabilised.

That doesn’t mean you should ignore adverse information.

It means you should understand it.

There is a difference between:

“Something happened five years ago.”

and

“This person is currently failing to maintain several financial commitments.”

Referencing should help you make an informed decision, not simply generate a red or green light.

Previous Landlord References Can Help

Where available, a previous landlord reference can provide useful information about somebody’s rental history.

You might want to establish:

  • Was the rent paid?
  • Was the property looked after?
  • Were there significant tenancy breaches?
  • Would the landlord rent to them again?

But treat references sensibly.

Remember that the previous landlord may have their own motivations.

An excellent reference isn’t an absolute guarantee.

A negative reference may also need context.

Where information appears inconsistent with everything else you’ve received, investigate rather than immediately making assumptions.

What If the Tenant Has Never Rented Before?

Everybody has to be a first-time tenant once.

Someone living with parents may have no previous landlord reference.

That doesn’t automatically make them a bad applicant.

Instead, other evidence becomes more important.

You may place greater weight on:

  • Income.
  • Employment.
  • Credit referencing.
  • Savings.
  • Identity checks.
  • A guarantor where appropriate.

The lack of rental history is simply that.

A lack of rental history.

It isn’t adverse rental history.

Should I Ask for a Guarantor?

A guarantor can sometimes help where an applicant doesn’t meet the usual affordability requirements.

For example, the applicant could be:

  • A student.
  • Starting their first job.
  • Recently self-employed.
  • On irregular income.
  • Otherwise marginal on affordability.

A guarantor normally agrees to become financially responsible for obligations under the tenancy if the tenant fails to meet them, subject to the wording and enforceability of the agreement.

You should reference the guarantor appropriately too.

There’s little value having a guarantor who couldn’t afford to honour the guarantee.

And because guarantee agreements can create significant legal obligations, the documentation needs to be properly drafted.

Can I Ask for Six Months’ Rent Upfront Instead?

This is where landlords need to be particularly careful with old advice.

The rules changed in England from 1 May 2026.

For relevant assured tenancies, landlords and letting agents cannot ask for, encourage or accept rent before the tenancy agreement has been signed.

Once the agreement has been signed and you’re in the pre-tenancy period, the amount of rent that can usually be requested in advance is limited to one month’s rent where rent is paid monthly, or 28 days where it isn’t.

There are limited exceptions.

So the old strategy of solving every referencing problem by demanding six or twelve months’ rent upfront is not something landlords should assume is still available.

Make sure any rent-in-advance request complies with the current rules.

Can I Charge the Tenant for Referencing?

Generally, no.

Tenant referencing isn’t something you can simply pass on to the prospective tenant as an application fee.

The Tenant Fees rules restrict the payments landlords and letting agents can require.

Your normal costs of checking an applicant are part of operating your rental business.

You can, however, take a permitted holding deposit while referencing is carried out.

How Much Can a Holding Deposit Be?

In England, a holding deposit can generally be up to one week’s rent.

It is intended to reserve the property while checks are completed.

There are rules governing what happens to that money and when it must be refunded.

Don’t treat a holding deposit as free compensation simply because you’ve decided not to proceed.

Whether it can legitimately be retained depends on the circumstances.

And make sure you don’t continue taking multiple holding deposits for the same property without understanding the rules applying to the first one.

Don’t Start a Rental Bidding War

Another major change from 2026 concerns rental bidding.

If you’re advertising an assured tenancy in England, you need to state a specific asking rent.

You cannot then:

  • Ask applicants to offer more.
  • Encourage them to bid against each other.
  • Suggest they’ll have a better chance if they increase their offer.
  • Accept an offer above the advertised rent.

Imagine you’ve advertised the property for £1,400 per month.

One applicant says:

“I’ll pay £1,500 if you give it to me.”

It might be tempting.

Under the current rules, you should not accept that higher bid.

Tenant selection should be about identifying an appropriate applicant, not creating an auction.

Be Very Careful With Social Media “Research”

It can be tempting to type a prospective tenant’s name into Facebook or Instagram and start investigating.

But think carefully about what you’re doing.

You are processing somebody’s personal information to make a decision that could significantly affect them.

Data protection law applies to landlords too.

Tenant data should be:

  • Collected lawfully.
  • Used fairly.
  • Relevant to the purpose.
  • Kept secure.
  • Retained only as long as appropriate.

Collecting information simply because you can find it online isn’t automatically good screening practice.

Social media can also expose you to information about protected characteristics that should have no bearing on your decision.

A structured referencing process is far safer than disappearing down somebody’s Instagram feed looking for reasons not to like them.

Landlords Have Data Protection Responsibilities

During referencing, you can end up holding a remarkable amount of personal information.

Potentially:

  • Names.
  • Addresses.
  • Dates of birth.
  • Employment information.
  • Income.
  • Bank information.
  • Identification documents.
  • Immigration information.
  • Credit information.

That’s sensitive material.

You need to understand why you’re collecting it, use it appropriately and keep it secure.

Don’t leave copies of passports sitting unprotected in an email inbox indefinitely.

Don’t collect documents you’re never going to use.

And don’t keep unsuccessful applicants’ information forever simply because storage is cheap.

Depending on how you process personal information, you may also need to consider your obligations to the Information Commissioner’s Office.

Using a Letting Agent Doesn’t Remove Your Responsibilities

A good letting agent can take a lot of administration away from you.

They can:

  • Market the property.
  • Carry out viewings.
  • Arrange referencing.
  • Complete Right to Rent checks where agreed.
  • Prepare documentation.
  • Manage the tenancy.

That can be particularly useful for a first-time landlord.

But don’t assume:

“The agent handles it, therefore none of this concerns me.”

Understand what your agent is doing.

Ask what referencing company they use.

Ask what criteria they apply.

Ask how applicants receiving benefits are assessed.

Ask who completes Right to Rent checks.

Ask how personal data is handled.

And make sure you understand who remains legally responsible for each part of the process.

Current rental-discrimination rules can also apply to people acting on your behalf.

Outsourcing a discriminatory decision doesn’t magically make it lawful.

What Should I Do If Two Tenants Both Pass Referencing?

This is where having predetermined criteria helps.

Perhaps both applicants:

  • Meet the affordability requirements.
  • Pass credit referencing.
  • Have acceptable references.
  • Have the Right to Rent.
  • Can move within the required timeframe.

You still have to choose.

I’d use objective factors relevant to the tenancy rather than making assumptions based on personal characteristics.

For example:

  • Which tenancy start date works?
  • Is the household suitable for the property and any lawful occupancy limits?
  • Have all requested documents been provided?
  • Does either applicant require arrangements you cannot reasonably accommodate?

Document why you made the decision.

You don’t need a 14-page underwriting report.

You just want to be able to demonstrate that the choice wasn’t arbitrary or discriminatory.

Can I Refuse a Tenant Because They Have a Pet?

This is another area affected by the Renters’ Rights reforms in England.

Tenants and prospective tenants can request permission to keep a pet.

Landlords need to consider requests fairly and should only refuse where there is a valid reason.

That doesn’t mean every pet request has to be accepted regardless of the circumstances.

But:

“I never allow pets because I don’t like them”

is no longer a sensible starting point.

Consider the actual property, proposed pet and circumstances.

What Are the Biggest Tenant-Screening Mistakes?

The pattern I see is that mistakes tend to come from one of two extremes.

The first is doing almost nothing.

The landlord likes the applicant, takes a deposit and hands over the keys.

The second is trying to investigate everything.

Bank statements.

Social media.

Personal questions.

Employment.

Family.

Lifestyle.

Anything else they can discover.

Neither is ideal.

A better process sits in the middle.

Collect the information you genuinely need.

Verify it.

Apply the same reasonable standards consistently.

Follow the law.

Then make a documented decision.

A Sensible Tenant-Screening Process

If I were approaching tenant selection as a landlord, I’d want the process to look roughly like this:

1. Set the rent and screening criteria before advertising.

Know what evidence you’ll require.

2. Take applications consistently.

Ask serious applicants for broadly the same relevant information.

3. Check affordability.

Use realistic, non-discriminatory criteria and consider qualifying income appropriately.

4. Verify income and employment where relevant.

Don’t simply accept figures without appropriate evidence.

5. Carry out appropriate credit referencing.

Understand adverse information rather than relying solely on a pass/fail score.

6. Check previous rental history where available.

But don’t penalise somebody simply for being a first-time tenant.

7. Complete Right to Rent checks in England.

Check every relevant adult consistently.

8. Assess any guarantor properly.

A guarantee is only useful if it is meaningful and enforceable.

9. Handle deposits correctly.

Understand the rules for holding and tenancy deposits.

10. Document the decision.

Keep a sensible record of how the applicant was assessed.

That’s far more robust than:

“They seemed nice.”

Screening Doesn’t Guarantee a Perfect Tenancy

This is important.

You could carry out every reasonable check and still encounter problems later.

Somebody with an impeccable rental history can lose their job.

A relationship can break down.

A tenant can become seriously ill.

Financial circumstances change.

Tenant screening reduces uncertainty.

It doesn’t eliminate it.

That’s why landlords still need financial resilience.

If your mortgage becomes unaffordable the moment one rent payment is late, your problem isn’t only tenant selection.

It’s the financial structure of the investment.

Keep an Emergency Fund

I regularly emphasise this when discussing Buy-to-Let with landlords.

Rental income is not guaranteed.

You may experience:

  • Arrears.
  • A void period.
  • Repairs.
  • Legal expenses.
  • Insurance excesses.
  • An unexpected mortgage-cost increase.

That doesn’t mean Buy-to-Let is necessarily inappropriate.

It means you need to treat it as a business with financial risk.

I’d rather see a landlord retain sensible cash reserves than put every available pound into a deposit simply to achieve a slightly lower mortgage rate.

Frequently Asked Questions

What checks should I carry out on a new tenant?

Typical checks can include identity, affordability, income or employment, credit referencing, previous landlord references and Right to Rent checks in England. The appropriate checks depend on the tenancy and circumstances.

Do landlords have to carry out credit checks?

There is no general requirement that every private landlord must conduct a commercial credit check, but credit referencing can form a useful part of assessing an applicant’s financial position.

Can I reject a tenant because they’re on Universal Credit?

You can reject an applicant who genuinely cannot afford the property based on a fair affordability assessment. However, landlords in England must not discriminate against somebody because they receive benefits, and benefit income should not simply be ignored when assessing affordability.

Can landlords say “no children”?

Landlords in England must not discriminate against prospective tenants because they have children. Legitimate property issues such as legal occupancy limits still need to be considered.

Can I charge tenants for referencing?

Generally, tenant-referencing fees cannot simply be charged to the applicant under the Tenant Fees rules in England.

How much holding deposit can I take?

A holding deposit in England can generally be no more than one week’s rent, subject to the rules governing holding deposits.

Can I ask for six months’ rent upfront?

For relevant assured tenancies in England from 1 May 2026, landlords cannot ask for or accept rent before the tenancy agreement is signed, and the amount usually payable in advance during the pre-tenancy period is restricted. The old practice of routinely requesting six or twelve months’ rent upfront should not be assumed to remain permitted.

Do I need to check every tenant’s Right to Rent?

In England, Right to Rent checks generally need to be carried out on every adult who will occupy the property as their only or main home, regardless of nationality.

Should I use a professional tenant-referencing company?

You don’t necessarily have to, but a professional service can make the process easier and more consistent. You should still understand what is being checked and ensure the process you or your agent uses is lawful.

Final Thoughts

So, how do you screen tenants without making mistakes?

I don’t think the answer is finding the most aggressive referencing service available.

And it certainly isn’t relying entirely on gut instinct.

It’s having a repeatable, fair and documented process.

Check the things that matter.

Affordability.

Identity.

Rental history where available.

Credit information where appropriate.

Right to Rent.

Then make the decision based on relevant evidence.

The 2026 changes also mean landlords need to be particularly careful about old habits such as blanket “no benefits” policies, refusing families with children, accepting higher rental bids or demanding large amounts of rent upfront.

Good landlords don’t need to find the mythical “perfect tenant”.

They need to make a reasonable decision using good information and then remain financially prepared for the fact that people’s circumstances can change.

That’s a much more realistic approach to managing rental risk.

If you’re buying your first rental property, adding to an existing portfolio or reviewing the mortgage on a property you already let, you can book an appointment with me here:

https://website.csc-financial.co.uk/dan-appointment

Your property may be repossessed if you do not keep up repayments on your mortgage.

Most Buy-to-Let mortgages are not regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. Consumer Buy-to-Let mortgages are subject to a separate regulatory framework.

Rental income is not guaranteed and property values can fall as well as rise. Mortgage availability and suitability depend on individual circumstances, the property and lender criteria.

Landlord and tenancy law differs across the UK. The legal information in this article primarily relates to private residential tenancies in England and reflects the rules in force at the time of writing. Landlords should obtain appropriate legal advice where they are unsure of their obligations. This article provides general information only and does not constitute mortgage, legal, tax or investment advice.

Let's talk about your next property

A free, no-pressure conversation about what you're planning, and an honest view on whether it stacks up.